dilsey arrington evans

1816-death unknown

Life Story

Faith, Marriage, and Family Across the Boundaries of Slavery


Early Life and Enslavement

Dilsey Evans, also recorded as Dilsy and Dillie Evans, was born around 1816–1820 in the American South. Her birthplace was recorded differently in the surviving federal census records. The 1870 census identified Mississippi as her birthplace, while the 1880 census recorded Alabama. The latter enumeration also identified South Carolina as her father’s birthplace and Virginia as her mother’s.¹

These differences reflect the difficulties of reconstructing the early lives of African Americans who spent much of their lives enslaved. Their ages, birthplaces, and family relationships were not always consistently recorded, and the federal slave schedules generally omitted their names.

Dilsey’s parents and the circumstances of her childhood remain unknown. By the 1850s, however, she was associated with the enslaved African American community of Ezekiel Arrington in Newton County, Mississippi.

The surviving records of Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church preserve an important part of her history, documenting her religious membership years before emancipation.

Her appearance in those records also provides a possible explanation for how she developed a relationship with George Evans, an enslaved man belonging to Catherine McInnis Evans, who later became her husband.


The Arrington Household and the Religious Community

During the years before the Civil War, Ezekiel Arrington was associated with Bethel Baptist Church, where he was a member. Several African Americans enslaved by Arrington also appeared in the surviving Bethel Baptist membership records.

Dilsey’s religious affiliation followed a different pattern.

Rather than appearing among the identified members of Bethel Baptist Church, she was recorded in the membership register of Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, where she was associated with E. Arrington.²

Of particular significance, Dilsey is the only person associated with E. Arrington identified in the surviving List of Colored Members at Mount Moriah.

This distinction raises an important historical question. Why did Dilsey become a member of a Presbyterian congregation when her enslaver and several other people associated with his household belonged to a Baptist church?

The answer may lie in her relationship with George Evans.

George, who was enslaved by Catherine McInnis Evans, had already become a member of Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church before Dilsey entered the congregation.

Their later documented marriage provides an important connection between the two individuals and suggests that their religious lives may have intersected before emancipation.


July 24, 1853: Dilsey Joins Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church

On July 24, 1853, the Session of Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church received Dilsy, associated with the Arrington household, into church membership.³

At the same meeting, Dolly, enslaved by Roderick McCraney, and Peter, enslaved by Catherine McInnis Evans, were also received.

The minutes specifically recorded the baptisms of Peter and Dolly. They did not record a baptism for Dilsey on that date.

Dilsey’s admission is important for several reasons.

First, it establishes her presence in Newton County’s African American Presbyterian community more than a decade before the abolition of slavery.

Second, it identifies her through the Arrington household, providing a connection to the enslaved population recorded in Ezekiel Arrington’s federal slave schedules.

Third, it places her within the same congregation as George Evans, who had been received into membership approximately five years earlier.

George’s earlier admission occurred in February 1848, when the Session examined, baptized, and received him as a servant of Mrs. C. Evans.⁴

By the time Dilsey joined in July 1853, George was already an established member of the congregation.

This chronology becomes especially meaningful when considered alongside their later marriage.


A Religious Connection to George Evans

Dilsey’s decision to join Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church may have been influenced by her relationship with George Evans.

The circumstances surrounding their church memberships are unusual enough to warrant close examination.

George was enslaved by Catherine McInnis Evans, while Dilsey was associated with Ezekiel Arrington. Although the two individuals belonged to different enslaving households, both became members of Mount Moriah.

Meanwhile, Ezekiel Arrington and several other African Americans associated with his household attended Bethel Baptist Church.

Dilsey’s membership at Mount Moriah therefore differed from the religious pattern documented for other members of the Arrington enslaved community.

If George and Dilsey were already courting or maintaining a marital relationship by 1853, her admission to Mount Moriah may have allowed them to share religious services and participate in the same congregation.

For enslaved husbands and wives held by different enslavers, opportunities to spend time together could be restricted by work obligations, travel distances, and the permission of those who enslaved them.

Church gatherings sometimes provided opportunities for enslaved African Americans from different households to maintain personal relationships and participate in a shared community.

An alternative possibility is that George and Dilsey became acquainted through Mount Moriah and developed their relationship afterward.

The surviving records do not establish when their relationship began. Nevertheless, George’s earlier membership, Dilsey’s subsequent admission, and their later documented marriage provide a meaningful basis for considering a connection between their religious affiliation and family life.


Maring Evans: Evidence of a Family Before Emancipation

The 1870 United States census provides another important clue concerning the early relationship between George and Dilsey.

Living in their household in Jasper County, Mississippi, was Maring Evans, a fifteen-year-old Black female whose estimated birth year was 1855.⁵

If Maring was George and Dilsey’s daughter, her birth would place the formation of their family within approximately two years of Dilsey’s admission to Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church.

This sequence is significant.

George had entered the congregation in 1848. Dilsey followed in 1853. Maring was born around 1855.

If Maring was their child, George and Dilsey were likely maintaining a family relationship during the final decade of slavery.

Such a relationship would have existed despite their association with different enslaving households.

The possibility also gives additional meaning to Dilsey’s choice of congregation. Her membership at Mount Moriah may have been connected not only to religious faith but also to her developing relationship with George.

However, the 1870 census did not identify relationships between household members. Maring’s presence in their household does not independently establish that she was their daughter.

The surviving records also do not establish whether George and Dilsey were formally married before emancipation or whether their relationship developed into marriage afterward.

Even with these limitations, the chronology offers an important glimpse into the possible formation of their family under slavery.


Dilsey and the 1860 Slave Schedule of Ezekiel Arrington

The 1860 United States slave schedule for Newton County, Mississippi, recorded numerous African Americans enslaved by Ezekiel Arrington.

Among those enumerated was a forty-year-old Black woman, whose estimated birth year of 1820 corresponds closely with Dilsey’s age in the 1880 census.⁶

The Mount Moriah membership register independently identifies Dilsey as associated with E. Arrington.

Together, the church record and the slave schedule provide evidence for identifying the forty-year-old woman as Dilsey.

The identification is supported by the consistency of her approximate age, her documented association with Arrington, and her presence in the same Newton County community.

However, because the slave schedule did not identify enslaved people by name, the specific entry cannot be conclusively assigned to Dilsey without additional documentation.

The schedule also recorded enslaved children and adults of different ages, reflecting the larger community held in bondage by Arrington.

The records do not establish Dilsey’s particular duties or identify any children she may have had while enslaved.

If Maring Evans was her daughter, the child’s birth around 1855 would place her within the Arrington enslaved community during the years before emancipation.

Further examination of Arrington family estate records, probate documents, and other surviving records may help clarify these relationships.


Emancipation and the Beginning of Freedom

Dilsey lived through the Civil War and the abolition of slavery in Mississippi.

By 1865, she was approximately forty-five to forty-nine years old, having spent most of her life under slavery.

The surviving records do not describe the circumstances of her emancipation or establish precisely where she was living when slavery ended.

For African American women like Dilsey, freedom brought a fundamental change in legal status, although economic hardship and racial discrimination continued to shape everyday life.

One of the most important consequences of emancipation was the opportunity for formerly enslaved families to live together without the legal authority of enslavers to sell or separate them.

By 1870, Dilsey and George Evans were living together in Jasper County, Mississippi.

Their household provides evidence of a family established during the years immediately following emancipation and possibly formed much earlier.


The Evans Household in Jasper County, 1870

The 1870 United States census recorded Dilsey Evans, age fifty-four, living in the Northeast Beat of Jasper County, Mississippi, with Garlandsville listed as her post office.⁷

Her birthplace was recorded as Mississippi, and her occupation was listed as keeping house.

The census also indicated that she could neither read nor write.

Dilsey lived in dwelling number 107 with George Evans and three additional individuals.

NameAgeRecorded information
George Evans54Farmer; born in South Carolina
Dilsey Evans54Keeping house; born in Mississippi
Maring Evans15Born around 1855
George Evans5Born around 1865
Silas Evans74Household member

The household reveals several important aspects of Dilsey’s life.

George was working as a farmer, while Dilsey was recorded as keeping house. Together, they were part of a free African American household during Reconstruction.

Maring Evans, age fifteen, provides a possible connection to their family life before emancipation.

The younger George Evans, age five, was born around the time slavery ended. His presence in the household and his continued residence with the couple in 1880 provide another important link between the two census records.

Silas Evans was also enumerated in the household, although his age differs between the supplied census transcriptions. His relationship to Dilsey and George remains undetermined.

Because the 1870 census did not record household relationships, the precise connections among these individuals require additional evidence.

Nevertheless, the enumeration preserves Dilsey’s name and household during the first federal census conducted after emancipation.


A New Home in Lauderdale County, 1880

By 1880, Dilsey and George Evans had relocated from Jasper County to Tunnel Hill, Lauderdale County, Mississippi.

The federal census recorded Dilsey under the name Dillie Evans, age sixty, living in dwelling number 361.⁸

Unlike the 1870 census, the 1880 enumeration explicitly identified relationships to the household head.

Dillie was recorded as the wife of George Evans, confirming their marital relationship.

The household included:

NameAgeRelationship or status
George Evans60Head; farmer
Dillie Evans60Wife; housekeeper
George Evans15Household member

The younger George’s age corresponds with the five-year-old boy recorded in the couple’s 1870 household.

The consistency of the household members supports the identification of Dilsey Evans in 1870 and Dillie Evans in 1880 as the same woman.

The 1880 census also provides additional information about Dilsey’s family origins.

Her birthplace was recorded as Alabama, while her father’s birthplace was listed as South Carolina and her mother’s as Virginia.

Although the names of her parents remain unknown, these entries offer clues for future research into her ancestry and the movement of enslaved families across the South.

Dilsey’s occupation was recorded as housekeeper, while George continued working as a farmer.

The census does not establish whether the family owned or rented its home or why it relocated to Lauderdale County.

Their move nevertheless documents the family’s continued presence in Mississippi during the years following Reconstruction.


Family Relationships Across Slavery and Freedom

The history of Dilsey and George Evans is particularly meaningful because their relationship may have begun while they were enslaved by different families.

The Mount Moriah records identify George with Catherine Evans and Dilsey with E. Arrington.

Their membership in the same congregation provides evidence that their lives intersected within the religious community of Newton County.

The possible birth of Maring Evans around 1855 adds another dimension to this history.

If Maring was their daughter, George and Dilsey had begun building a family at least a decade before emancipation.

Their continued residence together in 1870 and 1880 demonstrates the endurance of their relationship into freedom.

The younger George Evans also provides an important avenue for tracing the family’s descendants.

Future research may clarify whether Maring and the younger George were the couple’s biological children, whether Silas Evans was related to either parent, and whether other children were born to the family.

These questions are especially important because family relationships among enslaved African Americans were often omitted from official records.

Church membership registers, census enumerations, marriage records, and estate documents must therefore be examined together to reconstruct the relationships that slavery frequently left undocumented.


Later Years and Unanswered Questions

The 1880 census is the latest record presently identified for Dilsey Evans.

At approximately sixty years old, she was living with George in Lauderdale County, Mississippi.

Her death date and burial location remain unknown.

It is not established whether she remained in Lauderdale County for the remainder of her life or returned to Jasper or Newton County.

Several questions remain central to her history.

The first concerns the beginning of her relationship with George. Their shared membership at Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church suggests a connection before emancipation, but the date of their marriage remains undocumented.

The second concerns Maring Evans. Establishing whether Maring was Dilsey’s daughter could provide important evidence of the family’s formation during slavery.

The third concerns Dilsey’s life within the Arrington household. Additional records may identify her by name, establish her occupation, or reveal family relationships not preserved in the slave schedules.

Finally, tracing the younger George Evans into adulthood may help identify descendants and provide additional information about his parents.


Remembering Dilsey “Dillie” Evans

The life of Dilsey “Dillie” Evans reveals how church records and federal census enumerations can be brought together to recover the experiences of an African American woman whose life spanned slavery and freedom.

Born around 1816–1820, Dilsey was associated with the enslaved community of Ezekiel Arrington in Newton County, Mississippi.

On July 24, 1853, she was received into membership at Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, where George Evans, an enslaved man belonging to Catherine McInnis Evans, had already been a member for approximately five years.

Her membership was particularly distinctive because Ezekiel Arrington and several other African Americans associated with his household belonged to Bethel Baptist Church.

This difference raises the possibility that Dilsey’s relationship with George influenced her decision to join Mount Moriah.

The appearance of fifteen-year-old Maring Evans in the couple’s 1870 household adds another clue. If Maring was their daughter, her birth around 1855 would place the beginning of their family within two years of Dilsey’s admission to the congregation.

Following emancipation, Dilsey and George appeared together in the 1870 census in Jasper County, Mississippi. By 1880, they had relocated to Lauderdale County, where Dilsey, recorded as Dillie, was explicitly identified as George’s wife.

Their shared history offers a window into the personal relationships that connected enslaved African Americans across the boundaries of different households and religious congregations.

Although the surviving records do not reveal Dilsey’s own words, they preserve evidence of her religious membership, her association with the Arrington household, her marriage, and her life as a free woman during Reconstruction.

Dilsey’s story is more than the history of an enslaved woman who joined a church. It is the history of a woman whose religious life may have been closely connected to the formation of her family, and whose marriage to George Evans endured beyond slavery into freedom.

Her life deserves recognition within the history of Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, the Arrington and Evans enslaved communities, and the African American families of Newton, Jasper, and Lauderdale Counties, Mississippi.


Historical Sources and Footnotes

  1. 1870 U.S. Census, Northeast Beat, Jasper County, Mississippi, Garlandsville post office, dwelling 107, Dilsey Evans, age fifty-four, birthplace Mississippi; 1880 U.S. Census, Tunnel Hill, Lauderdale County, Mississippi, dwelling 361, Dillie Evans, age sixty, birthplace Alabama, father born South Carolina, mother born Virginia.
  2. Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, Membership Register, 6–7, “List of Colored Members,” entry 11, Dilsey, associated with E. Arrington. Mississippi Department of Archives and History, Jackson. For the broader Bethel Baptist membership context, see the surviving Bethel Baptist Church minutes and the compiled study, “The First Black Slaves and Freedmen at Bethel Baptist Church,” Black History of Newton County, Mississippi. The comparison of the congregations’ membership patterns is based on the records examined.
  3. Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, Session Minutes, July 24, 1853, 27, reception of Dolly, Dilsy, and Peter; Register of Baptisms, 190, July 24, 1853, baptisms of Peter and Dolly. Mississippi Department of Archives and History, Jackson.
  4. Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church, Session Minutes, February 27, 1848, examination, baptism, and reception of George, servant of Mrs. C. Evans; Membership Register, 6–7, entry for George associated with Mrs. Evans. Mississippi Department of Archives and History, Jackson.
  5. 1870 U.S. Census, Northeast Beat, Jasper County, Mississippi, dwelling 107, Maring Evans, age fifteen, enumerated with George and Dilsey Evans. The census did not specify relationships between household members.
  6. 1860 U.S. Census, Slave Schedule, Newton County, Mississippi, Ezekiel Arrington, enslaved Black female, age forty. The identification of this unnamed woman as Dilsey is based on age and association with Arrington and remains unconfirmed.
  7. 1870 U.S. Census, Northeast Beat, Jasper County, Mississippi, Garlandsville post office, dwelling 107, household of George Evans, including Dilsey, Maring, younger George, and Silas Evans.
  8. 1880 U.S. Census, Tunnel Hill, Lauderdale County, Mississippi, dwelling 361, George Evans, head; Dillie Evans, wife; and younger George Evans.

Resting Place

Unknown

Photos/Albums

Handwritten historical ledger page listing names, ages, and baptism records.

Leave a Reply